Canning & Preserving, Recipe Box

How to Can Tomatoes

Amber Shehan July 29, 2013

Make the most of tomato season by preserving your harvest and canning your tomatoes!

Canned Tomatoes

July and August are prime tomato time here in Western North Carolina!  The farm markets are crowing about the lovely boxes of heirloom tomatoes available for purchase, and the volunteer tomato vines left behind in our empty chicken coop are giving me handfuls of sweet cherry tomatoes every day.

As awesome as a fresh tomato can be, there’s only so many BLTs a person can stand (or so I’m told).  If you want to preserve that fresh flavor for winter months, you can always can your tomato harvest.

Be prepared to be warm! Canning produce involves a lot of heat in the form of boiling water, so enjoy your steam baths along with the lovely jars of red jewels you end up with.

Canning recipes and preserving techniques
Lovely jars of lovely tomatoes for lovely dinners to come!

Here is my step by step guide on how to can tomatoes using the water bath method.

I’ll quickly cover two different methods, both the Cold Pack and Hot Pack. They’ll all start off and end up the same, so let’s get started…

Canning Tomatoes

Get Tomatoes: You can use your own bountiful harvest, or that of your neighbor with too many plants, or grab a box of fresh ‘maters from your local farmers market! In general, seven large tomatoes will fill a one-quart jar.  Heavy, low-moisture tomatoes like Roma hold up the best, but as you can see from the images I’ve shared, Heirloom tomatoes preserve beautifully as well, if a bit watery.

Get Your Jars and Tools Together:  To can tomatoes without a pressure cooker, you will need the following equipment (the links are affiliate links – it doesn’t cost you extra to use them, but I get a small bit of compensation.)

  • Jars:  I usually use both quart and pint jars just to have a variety of sizes, and the rings to go with them. For ease, only process one size of jars at a time (one batch pints, then one batch quarts, etc.)
  • Lids and Rings: Do NOT reuse old jar lids. Go out and buy a pack of new lids. You can reuse the rings and jars, but it is not safe to reuse the inner lids.
  • Canning Pot:  You need a pot large enough to submerge your chosen size of jars under at least one inch of water, plus room for the boiling water to bubble. If you have a canning pot with a rack, wonderful! I do not, so I tend to use a big pot with a dish towel or two set on the bottom of the pot to provide a cushion for the jars while they are processing.
  • Tongs or Jar Lifter:  A jar lifter is worth the bit of expense, as tongs can be slippery to handle with heavy jars. The only burns I’ve given myself while canning was from using tongs to lift the boiling hot jars from the pot.
  • Small pan: You will simmer the new lids in this pot to sanitize them.
  • Medium pan: For boiling water to blanch and skin the tomatoes
  • Bowl of ice water: For shocking the tomato skins off.
  • Kettle: For the hot water to fill the jars.
  • Jar Funnel: I highly encourage the use of one of these…otherwise, it can be a huge mess!
  • Ladles and Spoons:  Long-handled tools are great to have on hand.
  • Lemon Juice: This is required to increase the acidity, and you won’t taste it at all!  It also helps the tomatoes to retain their color and flavor.

[content-egg module=Amazon template=grid]

The Process

Once you have all of your equipment together to can tomatoes, get to work!

Sanitize your jars.

If you have a dishwasher, you can sanitize your jars by running them through a wash cycle, with the water temperature set extra high.

If you do not have a dishwasher, rinse the jars and then fill your sink with boiling water, submerge the jars completely, and leave until ready to use.

Start the Canning pot.  Fill it about halfway, put the lid on, and let it begin to heat.

Start the Kettle heating.  This will be to fill the jars later on.

Boil the lids in the small pan for about five minutes, then turn down to low heat. Allow them to rest in the hot water until needed.

Remove the Tomato Skins. Wash your tomatoes and set up the bowl of ice water. While the water is coming to a boil, use a sharp knife to cut a small X in the bottom of each tomato for easier peeling.  You can also cut out the stem spot if you wish.

Set the medium pot of water to boil.  Once it is at a rolling boil, put a tomato or two carefully into the water. After about 30 seconds, the skin will crack.  Use a slotted spoon to remove the tomato and put it into the bowl of ice water. The skin should slide right off!

Cutting the Tomatoes (or not). Remove any bruised or icky spots and compost them.  Slice, dice, quarter…chop them however you wish, depending on whatever goals you have in mind for these tomatoes. You can also leave them whole if they are small, which is my preference.  Some folks remove seeds, but I leave them in.

There are now two different options to consider before you proceed: Hot Pack or Cold Pack. The difference in method mostly has to do with the standards for safety in canning.  I have used both methods with no problem, and without a discernible difference in results.

COLD PACK:  This means that you do not cook the tomatoes before you put them in the jars.  To use this method, proceed to the step called Fill the jars

HOT PACK:  This is considered a safer method to can tomatoes.  Simply add the chopped tomatoes to a pot and allow them to simmer for a bit. This also gives you a chance to season them if you wish, before adding the hot mixture to the jars and proceeding from the step “Fill the jars.”

Fill the jars: Use the funnel to pour the chopped tomatoes in, and use a wooden spoon to push them down gently to fill the jar up to within 1/4 inch of the top of the jar.  Wipe off all contact surfaces to ensure good, clean seals.

Add the liquid:

  • Add lemon juice: 2 tbsp per quart jar, or 1 tbsp per pint jar.
  • Fill up to 1/2 inch of the top with boiling water

Remove the Bubbles:  Use a butter knife, or the handle of a spoon, to carefully move around the edge of the jar.  This moves the tomatoes around, ensuring any air bubbles are released.

Put on the lids and rings:  Wipe down the jars first if needed.  Pull a lid carefully from the hot water, put it down on the jar, and snugly screw the ring on.  Do NOT tighten all the way.

Process the Jars: 

  • When the water in the canning pot is boiling, carefully add the jars one by one (or in a rack, if you have one).  Ensure they are covered with at least 1 inch of water, and keep the boiling going!
  • They should sit in the boiling water for about 40 minutes for pints, and about 50 minutes for quarts. Add more boiling water as needed to keep the water volume above the jars.

Remove the Jars:

  • Lift the jars out of the water VERY CAREFULLY.  Try not to let them bump or touch each other, and put them down on a clean dishtowel waiting on the counter.
  • Remove the rings as soon as they are cool, or at least loosen them.  Otherwise, they can rust into place.
  • Enjoy the popping of the seals as the jars cool!  If you haven’t heard that neat noise before, let me explain. As the jar cools, it pulls down the lid and it will seal with a *pop* – you can test this by gently pressing the center of a lid when the jars are cool.  If the center of the lid pops up and down, that is not sealed.  You can store that jar in your fridge to use soon.
  • The tomatoes will separate in the jar.  If you see chunks of tomatoes floating on a liquid layer, that is quite alright. You can avoid this next time by packing the jars a little tighter with tomatoes. (Check out my jars in the images I’ve shared above to see what I mean)

And there you are!  Once the jars are cool, it’s a good idea to label them with the date.  Try to use them up within one year – I just turned my last few jars into lovely spaghetti sauce for a party of friends. When you use them, it’s strain the tomatoes but reserve the liquid in case you need to add it back into a thick sauce.  It is easier to add liquid than remove it!

Please post your reactions, questions, comments, or concerns.  Do you can tomatoes at home?  What methods do you prefer?

Get updates from Pixie's Pocket: brewing and herbs in your inbox:

Amber Shehan

Hi! I'm Amber Pixie, and this is my site. Enjoy the recipes, information, posts, and please feel free to message me if you have questions!


  1. on July 29, 2013 at 2:39 pm

    great article!

  2. News, Links, and a Giveaway!) | Pixie's Pocket on October 22, 2013 at 9:13 pm

    […] How to Can Tomatoes article has been published in Healthy Recipes Magazine – a collection of paleo-focused […]

  3. […] How to Can Tomatoes — I have a bushel of tomatoes downstairs just waiting for me to finish up this post. And to get lemon juice; I seem to have run out. Sigh… […]

Leave a Comment